Mcnabb???

[BadBoy1313]

Being out here on the east coast I keep hearing rumors about The Eagles talking to the Raiders about trading McNabb for the #1 pick. Supposedly the Eagles aren't happy with McNabb anymore and are interested in Russell. Anyone out on the west coast hear anything about this? Any thoughts? Sorry I don't have any links or anything about it, just seems to be a hot topic in the local papers and t.v. around here.

[SCaliRDRFN]

our #1 pick? gosh....they can do better than just him.

[Sociofiend]

http://slam.canoe.ca/Slam/Football/N...432484-ap.html

Supposedly McNabb isn't going anywhere.

[heavyweight_4u]

All i read was that he was upset with the team because he wasnt allowed to travel with the team on the playoff trip. Which Reid has said No one travels on the IR. He was also upset that some anonimous players have stated that the eagles have a better shot with Garcia at the helm rather than Mcnabb.

[Sonic Raider]

Originally Posted by heavyweight_4u

He was also upset that some anonimous players have stated that the eagles have a better shot with Garcia at the helm rather than Mcnabb.

As well as those "anonymus" players should because McNabb is an overrated quarterback, he was basically Randal Cunningham pt. 2

Jeff Garcia, on the other hand, plays his balls off. I'd rather pick up Garcia for the Raiders than McNabb.

[Sociofiend]

That newspaper claims McNabb might assume some of his teammates feel that way, sounds like that paper just might be assuming things itself.

[Sociofiend]

Originally Posted by Sonic Raider

As well as those "anonymus" players should because McNabb is an overrated quarterback, he was basically Randal Cunningham pt. 2

Jeff Garcia, on the other hand, plays his balls off. I'd rather pick up Garcia for the Raiders than McNabb.

I'd take either one, minus the chunky soup commericals that McNabb does. I suppose I could live with it if he did produce well for us, hypothetically speaking.

[braytonismyboy]

well im not even looking into this because there isnt even a glimmer of that happening. Mcnabb is the qb of that team and will be for a while.

[Raiders4Life79]

McNabb is pretty much the franchise over there, so I don't see that as a possibility.

That said, I think McNabb would be a good addition to our team. Now, I used to be one of his doubters, saying he was a bit overrated. I still think he sometimes gets more hype than he deserves, but honestly, he is a great player. He is a team leader, a good QB, and with a new coach like ours, we need a guy like him. McNabb is always ready to learn, and as a leader, he can influence others. He is a good QB with great intangibles, which is something we need with such a young coach.

JMHO

[vegasraider26]

Hell will freeze over before the Eagles trade their franchise QB, the city of Philly is still IN LOVE with McNabb, he will retire as an Eagle. It would be franchise suicide (financially) if they were to trade McNabb.

[BossTycoon]

Although he is a good player... WE dont need anyone thats been hurt often.. I rather trade a LATER ROUND PiCk and GET JEFF GARCIA

[jidgemlb]

i dont think this trade will happen either. if we trade our #1 overall pick i dont want to get a NFL player in exchange. i would want to get more draft picks, just draft picks and lots of them

[btredway]

Too big of a contract, plus hes injured and may come back like Culpepper. I would rather take my chances with Russell

[or24]

1 word: OVERRATED

[BoJack247]

McNabb is not overrated. he was putting up monster numbers before he got hurt....and the bottom line is that they've been in the NFC title game 5 out of 7 years with a SB appearance to boot. could you imagine what he could do with both Moss and Porter?? if anything, outside of Philly, the guy is underappreciated for what he's done with the group of receivers he's had (outside of the year and a half he had with TO...and he should get props for putting up with that trainwreck).

Garcia is not better than McNabb. not even close. call it familiarity with the Eagles offense because of Marty Morningweg being their OC. someone's got to be smoking some serious crap to want Garcia over McNabb. Philly would never trade the face of their franchise.