Urgent!!! Trade Proposal - Oakland Raiders Forum | Message Board

**Sauce** · #1 (**permalink**) 10-17-2007, 04:19 AM

Sorry to sound so demanding... But I leave to go hunting tomorrow for a week and a half, so I need help with this one in a hurry...

My current lineup:

QB-Tom Brady
WR-Bobby Engram
WR-Antwan Randle El
RB-Willis McGahee
RB-Reggie Bush
W/T-Ronald Curry

BN-Vincent Jackson
BN-Lamont Jordan
BN-Chris Henry

I proposed this trade:

I get:

Roy Williams

I give:

Antwan Randle El
Chris Henry

(The team I proposed to put Carson Palmer, Roy Williams, Shaun Alexander, and Sammy Morris on the block)

He countered with this trade:

I get:

Shaun Alexander
Roy Williams

I give:

Antwan Randle El
Reggie Bush

What do you guys think... I'm kinda leaning towards it, considering I still have Jordan on the bench... The only thing is that this is a Points Per Reception type league, so Reggie has been piling up some points on that front for me... Also I'm currently in first place...

559Raider · #2 (**permalink**) 10-18-2007, 02:39 AM

At first glance it looks like a steal. But after looking into its not so good. Both Alexander and Roy Williams are real cold right now and Reggie Bush is barely getting rolling and since its a PPR league that should seal it. But check out what their avging. If Alexander and Williams barely beat out what Bush produces then thats a definite sign. Sorry I took so long to reply. Hope I didn't in time.

**hellbound** · #3 (**permalink**) 10-18-2007, 05:55 AM

both of those guys will outperform randle el and bush over the long haul.

**or24** · #4 (**permalink**) 10-18-2007, 06:16 AM

roy williams will bounce back in their pass happy offense in detroit.
Bush had a few good games against horrible defenses
alexander has lingering injuries and their line is horrible
randel el is realy hit or miss and even if he gets yds isnt a td machine
i like it just because of roy's potential

**yayarea_raider** · #5 (**permalink**) 10-18-2007, 02:43 PM

take that deal dude RIGHT NOW. ur givinf Randel El-a #2 wideout with some on/off games and reggie bush-a guy who is still adjusting for alexander-better than bush i would say at the moment despit last sunday and will be better for u and duh! R William makes this trade GODLY. Who said he was cold? he is a MUST START every week. I have him, yes, he recently (2 weeks ago) has a bad game, but **** happens. He remains a must start and do this deal right now. TRUST ME I'M VERY GOOD WHEN IT COMES TO FANTASY

**Midwest Raider** · #6 (**permalink**) 10-18-2007, 11:26 PM

I have Bush in both my leagues and I can't stand him. Sure, he is an NFL playmaker, but his goal line touches are outweighed by the fact that Brees is what he is. Bush doesn't have the size/power to shoot the A/B gaps like Deuce could have. I don't see him avging more than 4-5 pts per game. I say do it. Alexander and Roy Dub are always a consistant threat, and should give you a better edge.